• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Simplicity Rules

Adam DuVander on keeping it simple

  • About Adam

Help users write better headlines

May 7, 2007 by Adam DuVander

In any content, headlines rule. A good headline catches my attention and makes me want to read more.

When we have others create the content, they also supply the headlines. That means it’s up to we savvy web people to point them in the direction of better headline writing.

For WifiPDX, I asked reviewers to Give us the one sentence pitch. Why would you go here? It was a good thought, but there were two problems:

  1. This was the last field on the review page, despite being the most important
  2. It let to generic headlines like, “It’s great,” or confusing answers like “I wouldn’t” (go there).

Then there’s the case of BestPlaces CityViews, where visitors leave their comments on places (for example, Portland comments). I labeled the headline field “Title.” This most important part of a comment has been consistently misinterpreted.

Example text boxes, all labeled with Title

That’s right, people think that I am asking their title: President, Principal, Student, Human Resources Director, I’ve seen it all. To be fair, most people get this right. Since I have seen over 15,000 CityViews, this has happened enough that it’s a problem.

The fix could be as simple as calling it a headline. I could also provide a comment preview, so someone has a chance to make changes before committing. There’s probably even a little more guiding to be done.

If the goal is to generate good headlines, we can’t just give them an empty box. We need to help them fill it with good stuff.

BestPlaces in NYT

May 7, 2007 by Adam DuVander

Yesterday morning we walked down to Crema for a pastry, some coffee, and the Sunday New York Times. I knew there was a profile of Bert, the head researcher for BestPlaces. I didn’t know it would be plastered across the front page of the real estate section. Pretty cool.

BestPlaces in New York Times

The article was a pretty good overview of what we do at BestPlaces and has some pretty glowing quotes. I hadn’t heard this story about how Charlottesville reacted to being named the Best Place to Live in 2004:

The president of the chamber was so proud, Ms. Uriss said, that she had bumper stickers made up that proclaimed, “We’re the No. 1 City in America.”

They’ve slipped to number 17 this year, after their housing prices doubled.

“I guess we’ll have a lot of bumper stickers left over,” she said.

Platforms are simple and powerful

May 1, 2007 by Adam DuVander

Elliot calls Twitter a marketing wonder:

Twitter does not seem to market towards any need whatsoever and targets no one in particular. It’s just there.

Maybe it’s because Twitter was created to do something cool. And when you do something cool, you can just let other people market for you.

I think it’s more about the platform. Twitter being as simple as it is, you can use it for off the cuff self-expression, microblogging (or not), and several other possibilities.

Having a platform can be powerful, because you become the hub of many spokes. The simpler your platform, the more spokes you can have.

Don’t travel without Javascript

April 30, 2007 by Adam DuVander

Much of the Web relies on Javascript these days and thankfully most people have it on. If you’re creating a site for the general public, you still want to have a game-plan to deal with those surfing without it.

I looked at the top five travel booking sites, plus Yahoo! Travel, to see what they do. Booking travel is one activity I imagine is fairly consistent among all types of users. These six sites show a few different approaches to lack of Javascript.

The Security Gate Approach

Travelocity and Kayak both take a heavy-handed approach. They set up a security gate, where Javascript dogs sniff each incoming request. If Javascript is disabled, the guards kindly give you a customer alert.

Travelocity customer alert with Javascript disabled

Overall, I am against this option, but I can understand it. With only a small number of people without Javascript, it seems ridiculous to waste developer time being elegant. Toss up the security gate and be on your way.

While I never appreciate being told I have no choice, they provide clear instructions on fixing the problem. This is a simple solution without being too simplistic. Some sites that rely heavily on Javascript will probably need to use this method. A travel site probably isn’t that type of site.

The Deaf and Dumb Approach

The most common way to handle Javascript disabling is to ignore it. Any features on the site that use Javascript just won’t work. Depending on where the scripting is needed, you could be okay. Often it makes you look deaf to the user’s actions and dumb for not responding correctly.

Expedia, the largest travel booking site on the Internet, has a really big problem. When I click the ever-loving “Search for flights” button, nothing happens. My browser doesn’t move, because it isn’t doing anything.

Expedia deaf to user clicks when Javascript disabled

The search button is activated by a function that can’t be called if Javascript is disabled.

Yahoo! Travel, which I expected to knock this out of the ballpark, gave the craziest error of all. No matter what dates I enter into the search, it tells me they are too far ahead–even when I use their dropdowns and keep the automatically-selected options of a date three weeks from now.

Yahoo! goes cuckoo when Javascript disabled

If you plan to rely heavily on Javascript, have a plan for dealing with the disablers. If you don’t, you could end up looking deaf and dumb.

The “It Just Works” Approach

Orbitz and CheapTickets just work. I typed in some airports and dates, clicked a button, and I saw itineraries with prices… just like I would expect from a travel site, regardless of Javascript.

Complexity is a time hog

April 27, 2007 by Adam DuVander

Please wait...
Gerry McGovern with some great thoughts about simplicity on the Web:

We don’t pay for visiting a website with our money; we pay for it with our time. The longer we spend on a website the more we pay, so there is a strong motivation to spend as little time as possible.

A simple website charges you less time. A complex website charges you more time. Time is your most precious resource.

Sent to me by The Wheeze. Thanks to Beth Kanter for the photo.

  • « Previous Page
  • Page 1
  • …
  • Page 33
  • Page 34
  • Page 35
  • Page 36
  • Page 37
  • …
  • Page 85
  • Next Page »

Simplicity Series

  • Designing the Obvious
  • Paradox of Choice
  • Laws of Simplicity

Copyright © 2026 · Elevate on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in